Monday, October 11, 2010

Anti-Fan Death is Real?

Dear Korean,

Ever since I got familiar with the Korean entertainment industry I’ve wondered why fans over there are so aggressive. They attack verbally and/or physically celebrities they hate, other fans, or anybody with negative or even different opinion about their favorite star. The first time I read about “antifans” was when I read news about Korean celebrities. It seems to me that in Korea being an antifan of one celebrity is just as popular trend as being a devoted fan of another. Why?

Nell



Dear Nell,

Excellent question. The intensity of the so-called "anti-fans" in Korea is exactly as you describe, and this phenomenon dates back to the beginning of the corporate-produced boy/girl bands in the late 1990s. Perhaps the most infamous case of anti-fans involves Gan Mi-Yeon, a member of a bygone girl group called Baby VOX. She was targeted with extra intensity because she was rumored to be dating a rather popular member of a boy band. In a recent interview, Gan said throughout 1999 she received scores of "fan mails" filled with razors, apparently so that she would hurt her hand as she opened them, along with pictures of her with her eyes taken out or letters written in blood.

Physical attacks against celebrities by anti-fans are relatively rare, but they do happen -- and this should be distinguished from a more common form of violence against celebrities, such as stalking or kidnapping for money. In 2000, Yoon Gye-Sang, a member of a boy band called G.O.D. (not kidding about the name of the band) received a soda injected with bleach. Yoon's mother drank it instead and had to be hospitalized. Similarly in 2006, U-know of Dongbangshinki received a soda injected with industrial glue and was hospitalized also.

Gan Mi-Yeon during her years at Baby VOX

And then of course, there are the good ol' fashioned slams on the Internet. It seems like compared to the foregoing, bad things said on the Internet might feel like no more than a breeze. But they nonetheless cause real psychological damage. Recently a thesis written by actress Park Jin-Hee for her master's degree in social welfare caused a stir. In a survey of 240 actors, nearly 40 percent replied that they suffer from some level of depression, and have considered suicide. 20 percent took specific steps toward committing suicide, such as purchasing drugs. Park pointed to negative comments received through the Internet as one of the causes of stress suffered by those actors, along with more regular worries like career stability.

When the anti-fans are not attacking the celebrities they hate, they attack the fans of the celebrities they hate. The most infamous case would be the massive hair-pulling street fight between the fan club of H.O.T. and that of Sechs Kies, rival boy bands of late 1990s. Such actual conflicts have subsided since, but low-intensity versions of such conflicts happen to this day. For example, at a joint concert in 2008 featuring multiple boy/girl bands, the fan clubs of Super Junior and SS501 went quiet on purpose when Girls' Generation appeared on the stage. The concert organizers also paused the concert 20 minutes into the show because of potential clash between fan clubs.

How do anti-fans come to hate certain celebrities? As seen from above, it is often about rivalry and jealousy. But a worrisome number of anti-fans seem to hate celebrities "just because." When one reads the posts on the anti-fan sites (the Korean won't link them; he knows better,) the amount of blind hatred in the form of doctored pictures, baseless rumors and vile death wishes is simply stunning. There are some who attempt to give a somewhat rational reason (for example, one commenter at a Girls' Generation anti-fan site apparently hated the group because they were untalented,) but those people are few and far between, and the stated reasons are wildly disproportionate to the intensity of hate expressed on those sites.

To be sure, celebrities everywhere attract their fair share of hateration. As of this moment, 41,562 people "like" the "I HATE LADY GAGA" Facebook page. But the intensity of Korea's anti-fans and their willingness to do much more than quickly clicking the "like" button on a Facebook page are quite something else. What is it about Korea that contributes to this?

More after the jump.

Got a question or a comment for the Korean? Email away at askakorean@gmail.com.



First off, there is general level of intensity in Korea. It is not as if the Korean had a chance to carefully observe this across many different societies of the world, so the following statement is only anecdotal. But the Korean thinks it is probably fair to say that Korea is, overall, a more intense society than average. Korean people are passionate. Their emotions ride very high and very low, and their speeches and actions tend to be more unrestrained.

This is both good and bad. The high points of collective emotion is really an unparalleled high. To give a comparison point, in America, this type of high usually comes through sports -- probably the last arena in American life in which people are encouraged to drop most social niceties and go nuts together. This happens more frequently in Korea, and in more areas of life. And it feels really nice to be passionately exhilarated, not simply pleased, when good things happen. But oh, the bad side. The intensity running the other way can get scary, and the result is as described above.

(An aside: As bad as it is, the phenomenon does have a bottom. There has never been Korea's equivalent of John Lennon, i.e. a deliberate murder of a celebrity. One could argue, however, that Internet slams led to a number of celebrity suicides in Korea.)

But that alone is not sufficiently unique to Korea. Sure, Korea might be more intense in general and on average, but intense people are everywhere in the world. But the next factor is truly unique to Korea: it is a very, very interconnected country in every sense of the word.

Let us suppose that you are an American who passionately hate Lady Gaga, for whatever reason. How can you vent your hatred of Lady Gaga? Chances are, you are not within a 500 mile radius of Lady Gaga. Chances are you would not even know someone who knows someone who personally knows Lady Gaga. And chances are you are not very close to other people who hate Lady Gaga as much as you do.

All of those conditions are reversed in Korea. First, Korea is physically interconnected. It is a 50 million people country in which nearly 20 million people live in Seoul metro area. Everything important -- be it political, cultural, financial, anything -- is located in Seoul, which means every important person is in Seoul as well. Public transportation is very well developed such that even a 14-year-old with no car can travel every corner of the city on his own.

Korea is also relationally interconnected. In Korea, if you belong to a group, you are expected to be friends with everyone in the group. This does not mean it happens all the time, but it definitely happens frequently. For every school you attended (and sometimes for every grade level,) reunions are frequent. For every job you have, there are frequent departmental dinners (nominally voluntary, but not really in practice,) aimed toward building more personal bonds. In practicality, this means that without even trying very hard, Koreans get to know a lot more people personally.

Finally, Korea is virtually interconnected. Korea is one of the earliest adopters of high-speed Internet -- every interesting interaction between the Internet and the society in America happened at least 5 years ago in Korea. (e.g. social networking, political movements based on Internet, privacy issues, etc.) The Internet works in astounding speed. Smartphones are widespread. And nearly everyone is savvy about how to use and abuse the Internet. Anti-fans can organize over the Internet, further escalate their hate through dialog and even schedule flash mob meetings at the current location of a celebrity instantly.

These three factors combine to create a huge synergy effect in which no one is truly beyond the reach of the public. Supposed there is a celebrity X, a handsome gentleman in his late 20s. Anti-fan Y hates X, for whatever reason. If X and Y are in the U.S., there is very little Y can actually do to X. X is probably located in either Los Angeles or New York. There is very little about X's personal life that Y can know.

But in Korea, things are completely different. Y can join an anti-fan site with like-minded people, and keep her hatred burning for X by speaking with other people who also hate X. More people know X personally as he was growing up, and the stories involving the tiniest personal detail tell spread much faster over the Internet. Y can pick up those stories and tweak them into falsehoods that are much more personally damaging to X -- which again spreads over the Internet. Y can coordinate the release of those falsehoods with other members of her anti-fan site, and the volume of falsehood alone can make the story seem more credible.

If Y's motives are more insidious, Y can easily find out the whereabouts of X right at that moment, because the anti-fan sites could organize to spot X wherever he is. Both X and Y are probably within 30 mile radius, as they are likely to be both in Seoul -- which means Y can easily get to any place where X is using nothing about public transit and less than two dollars. From there, it is but a small step for Y to offer X a poisoned can of soda.

To an extent, the exact same thing happens elsewhere in the world. Recently Wall Street Journal carried an article about how fans of Liverpool F.C. protested against the hated owners of the team. Fans of Liverpool are much more well-organized compared to any anti-fan groups in Korea, and their reach is well beyond the U.K. And their tactics are exactly the same -- the articles speak of spotting the target of hate on the street, posting it up on the Internet, and the more reckless haters physically appear around the area to act out their hate. But in Korea, the physical barrier of doing something like that is rather low.

Got a question or a comment for the Korean? Email away at askakorean@gmail.com.

22 comments:

  1. I'd never heard of this phenomena before, really interesting post!

    Seriously though, who the heck drinks soda they receive in the mail? Are Korean celebrities that hard up for cash?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Food and beverages given to Korean celebrities are usually considered fan gifts. In the case of DBSK's Yunho, the juice spiked with super-glue was given to him by an anti-fan disguised as one of the staff.

      Delete
  2. wow O_O

    i... am lost for words... i never knew about the glue thing on yunho D:

    ReplyDelete
  3. But why so much people throw themselves into such troubles, when it's not productive at all?? It can't be compared, like example to what Banksy did with Paris Hilton, there is no meaning behind attacking someone with blood-written letters...those people should be more creative and establish a counter-culture or something, it's just ridiculous, that they are not aware of that how stupid is what they are doing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. youtube best proves this...heheh...you can see how low a fan can be, but of course, it isn't so in their perception

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm sorry but I didn't grasp the distinction you made in the last paragraph. Liverpool fans and Korean antifans seem exactly alike to me.

    Look at Tablo and what happened to him over his degree. The guy responsible, the equivalent of the Liverpool cab driver, actually conducting his campaign from Chicago or something, certainly in the US. Hate seems to cross the Atlantic and the Pacific in the same manner.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Korean people can be very superficial and cruel? That couple with the "Herd" mindset than this anti-fan phenomena is multiplied by several thousands!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Feisty, actually the sodas were hand-delivered to them as they were holding a public event.

    xoussef, you are right -- there is no real distinction. The only difference is that Korean anti-fans can act on their hate more easily.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I loved this parody k-pop video about antis.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bkIANBJ04M

    On another note, I don't understand why people like starting bad rumors about others. Really do they have nothing better to do?

    ReplyDelete
  9. @blueprincess824 - Yeah, and Heechul from Super Junior wrote back on his Cyworld, but was attacked for that too...

    There was this sad story of fans harassing a girl who took a picture with a member of Super Junior, ending with her killing herself..
    We can add the petition against Jay from 2PM, requesting him to commit a suicide...
    Tablo's affair about his degree, before airing the documentary showing the truth, he was harassed, his family too, leading his brother to quit his job...
    Antis going to events so they can throw something on the stars...(SNSD received hundreds of lightsticks at a concert...)

    Completely insane, mean and cruel.
    The worst is they don't even get the fact they're doing it to a human being...

    I just don't understand why no authorities are considering doing anything to protect their celebrities, as if they were thrown to the lions...

    Mad World...

    ReplyDelete
  10. I don't understand exactly.. Is it a lack of education?? I mean, are those people usually teenagers? Or what status those people have? Or is it just that they teach them to study at school but not to think? Is it that Korean society produces robots? Or since they have such pressure they need unconsciously a way to express themselves....

    ReplyDelete
  11. Look what happened with Jay Park and 2pm. An anti-fan dug through everything on all the members till they found a 4yr old comment on Jay's Myspace. They posted it out of context, and now Jay is no longer with the band he worked so hard to be a part of. The anti-fan recently admitted what they did and appologized. Really? Ruin a young man's career, and almost six others in the process, then say sorry. This type of thing needs to stop. Too many folks getting hurt.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Fans and anti's are both f*cking scary. o.o I can't believe how much I hear about psychotic netizens, it's like seriously? Do you have nothing better to do? =.= Omg, and those fans that pay the taxi drivers to help stalk their idol... Jeeze. I really like LEDApple's latest song which fights back against anti fans, and more idols are who starting to go out against it. They seriously need to chill, especially Sones, Cassies and ELFs... Holy sh*t they freak me out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sones aren't the crazy fans
      Most of the time snsd gets a lot of negative comments that why when some people insult snsd some sone take it personally and defend their bias. That just all but sones don't go around giving sodas with glue o food in bad state.
      We just support and defend our group without crossing the limits

      Delete
    2. Some bigbang fans are really crazy

      Delete
  13. An addendum: Jay Park has returned to the K-pop scene as a solo artist. He's not as well-supported now under SidusHQ as it's no longer one of the big guns in the industry, unlike JYP Entertainment.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The glue things for real?!!!!

    n how come the ELF do that 'thing' to SNSD? How come? Cant they support SME famili?

    Please ELF. Im ELF n Sone too. but, i will never do this like that. Because i know that our OPPAs will be sad because of us bad attitude!

    ReplyDelete
  15. I personally have an extreme dislike for the concept of celebrities, but it has nothing to do with the actual celebrity, mostly their fans.

    I tended to just ignore celebrities until 3 years ago, when I met my girlfriend and noticed her very Korean tendencies of knowing everything about every celebrity and kind of devoting a little bit too much time into learning about their lives, or being extremely interested in watching their shows, not because they're good, but because of a single person...

    I don't hate Big Bang, or SNSD (as examples), in fact, I love JYP! He is extremely successful and I use him a role model in developing my life. The dude is smart and successful. I do not simply watch a show because he is in it, but if he has valid information that can help me benefit my life I will definitely fall on it. I think THIS is what being a celebrity is all about. Real role models.

    As I grow older and see people drool over television programs or do something simply because so-so is in it, or so-so needs to take off his shirt, or so-so needs to wear super short shorts to show her legs, I get a little irritated. Maybe it is jealousy, but I think individuals should not hold a celebrity to such standards. I think celebrities should be used as role models, not as obsessions. When people watch television shows simply because Super Junior soso is on there, or Goo-hara is there, I get angry. I don't mind when people < 18 do it, it's understandable. Kids need something to relate to, need to be in that group.

    I feel when an adult does it, it's kind of unacceptable, childish, and it makes me hate the world I live in because people really have nothing better to do with their lives than read "news" about who is doing what.

    I guess I'm sort of an anti-fan, of the actual fans. I feel my reason is justified, but I think maybe someone could disagree with me. Of course, I would never say hateful things to anyone who was successful, or send them glue caps in a mail... That is just crazy. ANTI-FAN, ANNOYED PERSON, Neutral, INTERESTED PERSON, FAN. I think I fall under annoyed person.

    ReplyDelete
  16. You know a lot. Each blog post is like an entire dissertation. You ARE good at communicating. I recently stumbled onto South Korean TV shows and have discovered that I REALLY like Korea and Koreans. It's that passion that you talked about. What fun people. I want to learn to speak Korean but the language sounds like machine guns firing. I can barely get the vowel sounds when I hear it. I have strained my ear and managed to learn a few things but wonder if I could ever do it. I'd need some good resources. That's probably one thing you don't know, right? Since you're a native, you wouldn't have a need for that kind of knowledge. If you do, though, please share! Thanks. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. www.talktomeinkorean.com is a great resource to get you started. learn the alphabet first. This site: http://www.howtostudykorean.com/ has also been helpful. there are TONS of free and paid resources to study korean. mostly you just have to commit time to practice.

      Delete
  17. Great post! This was one of the many things I've noticed since becoming a fan of a few Kpop groups, especially Dongbangshinki and JYJ (I am convinced half of their fandom needs to be locked up actually...)

    I'm wondering if the same kind of mentality can be applied to the "sasaeng" fans? Those extreme group stalkers. When I read about the things they pull...with the taxi's, breaking into apartments, tapping into phones, stealing social security cards, trying to file for freaking MARRIAGE. It's INSANITY.

    ReplyDelete
  18. U;Nee has a lot hate mail from Anti fans, wanted her to die or demanding things that doesn't want to do like The Korean Version of Playboy, she tried to please but no they kept coming after her. By then they spewing rumors and hatred on her sexy image and she has a history of depression and a lot of sad memories of her childhood. And that drove her to suicide, died from hanging herself, it's a sad world we live in.

    ReplyDelete

To prevent spam comments, comments left on posts older than 60 days is subject to moderation and will not appear immediately.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...